Scoring panel member attacks BSBV review

Sutton Guardian: Vice chair of Sutton Link Doris Richards Vice chair of Sutton Link Doris Richards

A former nurse has criticised the NHS review that has put St Helier Hospital's accident and emergency department at risk of closure - after taking part in its scoring review.

Doris Richards, from Carshalton, is the vice chair of Sutton Link - a network which engages with the community to improve health and social care.

On Wednesday, February 13, Mrs Richards and 20 other representatives including clinicians and members of the new Clinical Commissioning Groups - that will run health services in Sutton when NHS London is disbanded at the end of March - were asked to review the scores a panel of eight experts had given three days previously as part of the Better Services Better Value review.

Last week sources revealed the expert panel has concluded St Helier and Epsom Hospitals were most suitable to lose their A&E and maternity services.

The review panel had the ability to hold a vote to change some of their proposed scores.

Mrs Richards, who was representing the views of Sutton Link, brought to the review panel the results of a survey carried out by 445 Sutton Link members.

The results showed 91 per cent felt that St Helier should retain its accident and emergency and maternity department.

Mrs Richards, who used to work as a nurse, said: "They should have had a plan for how they are going to deliver services in the community and deliver it effectively to people.

"We understand they want to have the best services and quality of services for residents in SW London. But it was what they were basing it all on that began to be a worry.

"There are five hospitals involved and none of them are meeting the London Health Programmes standards.

"Our question would be - why are they not working now to increase the standard of our hospitals?

"A lot of the standards could be achieved without reconfiguration. Why aren’t they trying to meet them now - that’s surely possible?"

She has also raised concerns about the ability of services in the local community to cope with closure of frontline services at St Helier Hospital given the recent problems at the Jubilee Health Centre in Wallington.

The Sutton Link survey has been acknowledged by BSBV.

 

Comments (1)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

11:51pm Fri 1 Mar 13

Michael Pantlin says...

If you are being kept alive with an incurable, serious but treatable condition and live alone you will find yourself in a dire situation each time you collapse feeling as sick as a pig. The A&E and AMU ward have been reconfigured to chuck you back out after a quick fix within a few hours to sink or swim alone at home in your bed. There is no one to pop in and check on you without the full social services assessment which will cost you around £12 an hour and be for just once or twice a day on a permanent basis so your money is wasted when you recover for a while. GP practices often have a week's wait to get an appointment while the out of hours home visit doctor is often a waste of time organising no tests and telling you to book an appointment with your GP when the weekend is over as he drives on to his next patient after a couple of minutes gathering his home visit fees.
The care has been surgically stripped from our NHS. Hospital staff are reduced to scientists and technicians and if you don't still believe the safe in their hands assurances the government will find a way of charging us for even that as soon as they can and by stealth.
If you are being kept alive with an incurable, serious but treatable condition and live alone you will find yourself in a dire situation each time you collapse feeling as sick as a pig. The A&E and AMU ward have been reconfigured to chuck you back out after a quick fix within a few hours to sink or swim alone at home in your bed. There is no one to pop in and check on you without the full social services assessment which will cost you around £12 an hour and be for just once or twice a day on a permanent basis so your money is wasted when you recover for a while. GP practices often have a week's wait to get an appointment while the out of hours home visit doctor is often a waste of time organising no tests and telling you to book an appointment with your GP when the weekend is over as he drives on to his next patient after a couple of minutes gathering his home visit fees. The care has been surgically stripped from our NHS. Hospital staff are reduced to scientists and technicians and if you don't still believe the safe in their hands assurances the government will find a way of charging us for even that as soon as they can and by stealth. Michael Pantlin

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree