Concerns raised over "serious rift" between Sutton Council and GPs

Labour's Emily Brothers said there is a serious rift between doctors and Sutton politicians

Labour's Emily Brothers said there is a serious rift between doctors and Sutton politicians

First published in News
Last updated
Sutton Guardian: Photograph of the Author by , Chief Reporter

A politician has expressed concern about a "serious rift" between the borough's doctors and its Liberal Democrat councillors.

Emily Brothers, Labour's parliamentary candidate for Sutton and Cheam, raised concerns after going to a meeting of Sutton Council's health and wellbeing board on Monday.

She said: "It is apparent that a serious rift has arisen between local GPs and Lib Dem councillors."

She also criticised Sutton and Cheam MP Paul Burstow for his decisions during his time as health minister.

Among the items discussed at Monday's meeting was a section about allowing council representatives to sit on the CCG's board.

When the board was instigated, it was decided council representatives should not be allowed on it to prevent a conflict of interests.

Despite this, Councillor Ruth Dombey, chairwoman of the Health and Wellbeing Board, denied there was any rift.

 

She said: “There was not a rift between the GPs and the councillors at the Health and Wellbeing Board, only a robust discussion about the future of healthcare in Sutton.

“Our Health and Wellbeing Board aims to work with the Sutton Clinical Commissioning Group and voluntary and community sectors and National Health Service England to find a solution to health needs for the borough.

“We did not approve the CCG’s five year strategic plan because councillors were not given the chance to help shape it. One area of particular concern is that it did not outline any plans to protect services at St Helier Hospital.

“Councillors would like to have the chance to contribute to the plan before it returns to a future Health and Wellbeing Board for approval.”

 

Following the meeting, Ms Brothers said: "I’m very concerned by the lack of trust between Lib Dem councillors and the GPs who run the Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG).

"I’m very conscious that the CCG has been presented with a longstanding thorny challenge.

"This hasn’t been helped at all by former health minister and local MP, Paul Burstow, putting in place the new architecture for a privatised health economy."

Among the health and wellbeing board's functions is the scrutiny of local medical provision, much of which is run by Sutton CCG.

CCGs were set up in the wake of the coalition Government's health and social care act in 2012 and give GPs more power over local provision and health spending although critics have said the bill facilitates what Ms Brothers referred to as a "privatised health market".

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

3:54pm Wed 2 Jul 14

Michael Pantlin says...

Plenty for the council health committee to monitor on Sutton GP services.
I handed in three communications to my local surgery at Wrythe Green about why I wanted them to support the continuation uncut of St. Helier Hospital and no one could be bothered to reply or acknowledge. I was discharged from St. Helier with plan for follow up support through the GP and when another crisis hit shortly after it took 3½ hours for a GP I've never seen or heard of to phone me and tell me to go to an online website for help. Quite apart from that one can phone the NHS Crisis Line during their opening hours and be met with a message taking system and your call is never returned. Community Care? No Community Krap I think.
Plenty for the council health committee to monitor on Sutton GP services. I handed in three communications to my local surgery at Wrythe Green about why I wanted them to support the continuation uncut of St. Helier Hospital and no one could be bothered to reply or acknowledge. I was discharged from St. Helier with plan for follow up support through the GP and when another crisis hit shortly after it took 3½ hours for a GP I've never seen or heard of to phone me and tell me to go to an online website for help. Quite apart from that one can phone the NHS Crisis Line during their opening hours and be met with a message taking system and your call is never returned. Community Care? No Community Krap I think. Michael Pantlin
  • Score: 6

12:47pm Thu 3 Jul 14

quizzfizz says...

In the last two weeks the BMA has come out and said that government health reforms have been an utter failure that put profits before patients and MPs from the Tory party have warned that the NHS will collapse within 5 years. I think its time to accept that the reorganisation of the NHS - which no-one voted for in the first place - has been a disaster and ask some hard questions of local MPs Paul Burstow and Tom Brake as to why they helped push it through in the first place.
I am glad to see the local council finally do what they should have been doing all along - scrutinising health plans that are more about cutting costs than meeting the needs of local people - and demanding transparency and accountability from the CCGs.
In the last two weeks the BMA has come out and said that government health reforms have been an utter failure that put profits before patients and MPs from the Tory party have warned that the NHS will collapse within 5 years. I think its time to accept that the reorganisation of the NHS - which no-one voted for in the first place - has been a disaster and ask some hard questions of local MPs Paul Burstow and Tom Brake as to why they helped push it through in the first place. I am glad to see the local council finally do what they should have been doing all along - scrutinising health plans that are more about cutting costs than meeting the needs of local people - and demanding transparency and accountability from the CCGs. quizzfizz
  • Score: 3

4:57pm Thu 3 Jul 14

Pippa Maslin says...

quizzfizz wrote:
In the last two weeks the BMA has come out and said that government health reforms have been an utter failure that put profits before patients and MPs from the Tory party have warned that the NHS will collapse within 5 years. I think its time to accept that the reorganisation of the NHS - which no-one voted for in the first place - has been a disaster and ask some hard questions of local MPs Paul Burstow and Tom Brake as to why they helped push it through in the first place.
I am glad to see the local council finally do what they should have been doing all along - scrutinising health plans that are more about cutting costs than meeting the needs of local people - and demanding transparency and accountability from the CCGs.
DITTO!
[quote][p][bold]quizzfizz[/bold] wrote: In the last two weeks the BMA has come out and said that government health reforms have been an utter failure that put profits before patients and MPs from the Tory party have warned that the NHS will collapse within 5 years. I think its time to accept that the reorganisation of the NHS - which no-one voted for in the first place - has been a disaster and ask some hard questions of local MPs Paul Burstow and Tom Brake as to why they helped push it through in the first place. I am glad to see the local council finally do what they should have been doing all along - scrutinising health plans that are more about cutting costs than meeting the needs of local people - and demanding transparency and accountability from the CCGs.[/p][/quote]DITTO! Pippa Maslin
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree