News RSS Feed


- Email photos and videos or text keyword SLNEWS with your message/photo/video to 80360.
- Sign up for Sutton Guardian's free email bulletins.
- Comment Register now to post your comments.
follow us:Twitter

Outside students invading Sutton grammar schools


More children from outside the borough attend Sutton’s top schools than those living here, figures show.

A census in May 2008 showed only 2,018 students from Sutton make up the 5,238 total population of the borough’s grammar school children.

The remaining 62 per cent of children come from outside of the area.

The news follows last week’s Sutton Guardian report that two of the leading grammar schools in Sutton are to withdraw guaranteed places for local children.

The 2010 admission proposals for Nonsuch High School for Girls and Wallington High School for Girls will give a greater emphasis to students with the highest marks living outside the area.

Since publication, the Sutton Guardian has received numerous calls from parents concerned at a “growing elitism’’ of selective schools in the borough which top the country’s league table.

Mother-of-two Louise Hassell said: “It’s a very unfair move and deeply unpopular.

“They appear very elitist proposals and will make it harder for local children to go to a local school of their choice.’’

At the time of the census there were 16,370 pupils in Sutton’s 14 secondary schools of which 11,132 went to the nine non-selective schools in the borough and 5,238 to the five selective schools.

Pupils attending non-selective schools from outside the borough made up 2,510 or 22.5 per cent.

League tables for 2009 show Wallington County Grammar School, Wilson’s School in Wallington and Nonsuch High School for Girls in Cheam were among the best 20 selective schools in the country.

Wallington School for Girls was also listed in the top 50 state secondary schools by the Sunday Times 2008 league table.

Since the Sutton Guardian reported the issue, both local Members of Parliament Tom Brake and Paul Burstow have expressed concern and said they would contact the schools to discuss the plans.

Leader of the opposition on Sutton Council Councillor Paul Scully said: “A notable minority of grammar school pupils actually live in the borough. We think this is unfair.

“We believe in Sutton’s schools for Sutton’s children.”

Wallington head Barbara Greatorex and Nonsuch deputy head Miss Jo Pomeroy both invited parents to express their concerns through official channels.

A Sutton Council spokesman said: “Sutton schools are among the best in the country and demand for places is very high. The schools use a set of criteria to decide which students to take. “For selective schools, where applicants have to pass the test, this can mean that applicants from outside Sutton get into the school, even if they do not live near it.”

Consultation on the proposals ends on Friday, February 20.


Your Say YourSutton

locallady, Wallington says...
2:17pm Thu 22 Jan 09

This needs to be looked into& reconsidered. I live in Sutton & I want my child to go to one of these schools next year.
I do not want my child having to travel to far to get to school & back. Sutton children MUST be given priority over those living out of the borough.

harbourshark, clapham says...
8:00pm Thu 22 Jan 09

locallady this ends the sex discrimination in Grammar education in Sutton. The boys'grammars have no protected places.Grammars are there to educated the most talented and not to be ring fenced because you can afford a more expensive property than others.

Anony Mouse, Sutton says...
1:12pm Fri 23 Jan 09

To Harbourshark - "because you can afford a more expensive property than others" You must've assumed that the local lady does in fact own her own property. I myself live in council property and I also want my daughter to go to a local school, not just because they are a good standard but strange as it may seem because I want her to be safe. I do not feel public transport is safe and unfortunately can't afford expensive cars. Obviously people from outside Sutton assume the wealthy minority are the majority. We have the largest council estate in Europe covering our Borough. Perhaps I should consider a move to leafy Clapham?

harbourshark, clapham says...
8:25pm Fri 23 Jan 09

To Anony Mouse

There is nothing stopping you sending your daughter to a local school, she will have to pass the test like any other girl and places are awarded on merit not postcode. Your lack of faith in public transport is not an admissions criteria.If you have sons that is the position they face.
Many residents of Sutton complain that the schools are being elitist,it is a GRAMMAR SCHOOL with an 11+ admission .Life has winners and losers, if I followed your argument you would want GCSE's to be for local children only. Schools are funded by all taxpayers so why should our daughters be excluded even when they score higher than locaL girls? If you had been monitoring these schools you would have known these changes were in the pipeline, the Heads of these schools have been complaining about to many tutored girls that cannot cope with the workload after they get in.
If you think Clapham is leafy come and live on the estates here, you dont worry about Public Transport you worry if you are safe in your own home.


locallady, Wallington says...
12:51pm Sat 24 Jan 09

I do not own my own property I am a council tennant and before you start assuming I'm a scrounger I also work 63 hours a week to pay my way.
I live in this borough & I expect my child to go to the best school in the borough, if she was to fail the exam (wich I don't think she will) then I would expect her to get priority over children out of the borough, especially this day & age where nowhere is safe.
Schools are supposed to follow the national curriculem so I wouldn't expect the workload to be any harder in any school, however the other schools in this borough do not have the excellent reputation that Wallington Girls have, plus I want my child to go to an all girls school.
Most of the unruly children at bus stops etc after school are out of borough children as well.
And to be honest if Clapham is so bad you fear for your safety why don't you move out after all if you can afford a Clapham home why not sell it, unless of course you are a council tennant like myself, then maybe you should exchange.

lizzyb, london says...
11:32pm Thu 29 Jan 09

This has everything to do with League Tables. Nonsuch is about 24th, and wants to be in the top 10. Tbe only way to do that is to become a total magnet school - attract the best from anywhere, as Tiffin Girls (No. 1) does, and devil take the local kids.

Nonsuch has always treated local residents with contempt - and here is more evidence of it. One huge issue which no one has so far mentioned is the impact on local roads of the increased traffic: when Nonsuch was mainly girls from Sutton and Epsom boroughs, traffic was bearable - now that the majority are from far away,it is unacceptable. If these plans go through, it will be absolutely appalling for local road safety. My son lives near there and he is fed up with parents speeding down his road to pick up their daughters - coming from Horsham, Guildford, Balham and so on.

Of couse what is really needed is a return to a proper Grammar school system, where every child has the chance to go up in the world. Fat chance of that - except of course for the kids of MPs, who nearly all go to private or Grammar schools.

lizzyb, london says...
11:39pm Thu 29 Jan 09

To 'anony mouse' - yes, staff at Grammar schools do complain that there are too many heavily tutored girls who pass the exam and then can't cope - but there is no evidence that these are local girls! In fact, the top banded passers are just as likely to find it hard to cope, since the Nonsuch exam is biased in favour of those good at Maths and word puzzles. I have been toldthat many of these girls can barely write a coherent paragraph - and they are just as likely to be from Clacton as from Cheam! Taking only those who pass high, is not the answer.

its life, Carshalton Beeches says...
10:29am Fri 13 Feb 09

League tables, league tables and more league tables!! Does this move not contadict the ruling at Warickshire at the moment? The Boys Grammars did away with their catchment a few years back, and now the Girls are to follow suit.
Do these GS expect these children(now from out of catchment-perhaps even Brighton...like the Boys!!) to travel over an hour in some cases to get to school???

Your sayYour Sutton

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE Sutton Guardian account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.


Local Links

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »