Grieving widow faces eviction from family home (From Sutton Guardian)
Contact us: Got a photo? Text SLPICS to 80360, click to upload your story or call
020 8722 6355
Young widow who lost parents and husband now faces losing Carshalton home
7:00am Friday 11th May 2012 in News Exclusive By James Pepper
A grieving young widow who lost her parents and husband in less than two years is now facing eviction from her family home.
Angela Green's new husband, Darren, was killed in a car crash in Mitcham in February and a month later she lost her father, Jim Tingley, through heart disease.
Her mother, Pamela, died two years ago after losing her battle with cancer.
Now, Sutton Housing Partnership (SHP) is using a legal loophole to force her out the home in Wrythe Lane, Carshalton, where she has lived in all her life.
A tearful Mrs Green, 29, who works in Fudge Cakes bakery in Carshalton, said: "I'm not sure there is anything to get up for any more to be honest. I would rather be asleep than awake.
"Darren's death really hit dad. They got on brilliantly, they would both gang up on me and take the mick. My dad had been fighting so hard against his illness, but when Darren died, it just killed him, he just gave up."
"Any memories I have of any of any of these people who are dear to my heart are in this home. I can look into the front room and see Mum and Dad dancing at her 50th birthday. This home is all I have left of them. I can't believe they are taking that away from me."
The newlyweds had had their hearts set on starting their own family in the home Mrs Green had grown up in, and the place where all new babies in the families are christened.
The Sutton Council-owned three-bedroom property on Wrythe Lane, Carshalton, was in the name of Mrs Green's parents, but when her mother died in 2010, the property was passed on to her father.
When her father became ill, Mrs Green tried to get the property transferred into her name was told she couldn't take the tenancy on as the house can only be passed on once.
On February 28, Darren Green, Angela's "wonderful and devoted" husband of only eight months, was killed in a collision on London Road, Mitcham.
Mr Green, 35, was killed when the silver Peugeot he was driving was involved in a crash with a refrigerated lorry in Mitcham.
Around 1,500 people showed up to send the "big friendly giant" off at North East Surrey Crematorium on March 14.
Mrs Green said: "It was the worst day of my life, I didn’t want to believe it. I still don’t really know what happened. All I know is that I have lost a amazing and devoted husband.
"Darren was, and is still, a truly exceptional person who I was proud to say was my husband."
Mrs Green, who lived in the home with new husband Darren while caring for her sick dad, was sent an eviction notice from SHP on Monday (30th April) following the death of her father in March.
SHP have offered her a one bedroom flat in the borough.
An on-line petition to keep Angela Green in her family home has been signed by nearly 4,000 people.
A spokesman for Sutton Housing partnership said: "We understand that these are very difficult circumstances for Mrs Green and we would like to offer our sincere condolences to her and her family.
"We do sympathise with her current situation but we have a duty to ensure that three bedroom council homes go to those families on the waiting list that are most in need.
"Under current legislation the Right to Succeed this tenancy had already been granted and therefore we are not able to grant Mrs Green further succession rights.
"In certain circumstances Sutton Council do however grant remaining relatives offers of alternative accommodation.
"SHP is currently working with the council and we have recommended that Mrs Green is given priority for a one bedroom home."
Related
Tributes to car lover killed in Mitcham crash
Floral tributes at crash scene
Comments(39)
Glen da menace
says...
10:03am Fri 11 May 12
Those who are friends with Angela, even if just on Facebook or because they knew Darren, see on a daily basis the heart break she has had to endure! It truly is so so sad that Angela has had to suffer so much in so short a time and at such a young age!
This is why I find it so hard to believe that Sutton council now feel it necessary to add to the trauma and evict Angela from HER HOME!!!
I understand the point that the tenancy had been passed on once already and that there are families who need a 3 bedroom place. I am 1 of those families (in a different part of the country) so know the frustration of having to wait.
My question is, can the council not exercise discretion at all in certain circumstances?
Personally I think that if Sutton council made the families in that borough waiting for a 3 bedroom place aware of all that Angela has been through, then these families would be more than happy to wait a while longer! No decent human being would want to be the 1 to take HER HOME away from her!!!
Much love to the Green family.
suttonmum
says...
10:10am Fri 11 May 12
AlphaBetty
says...
11:01am Fri 11 May 12
suttonmum wrote:Totally agree with Suttonmum. I understand that she's been through a lot, but this is a family-sized home. Previously living there for many years doesn't give you an automatic right to stay there forever.
It really is hearbreaking what this poor lady has gone through over the last 2 years, but the fact is she really doesn't need a 3 bedroom house. There are so many families in homes too small for them, and I don't mean those on benefits who continue having children. I mean hard working families who work hard and still cannot afford a suitably sized home for their families. If the council are prepared to offer this lady a 1 bedroom property, it should be accepted as many young women in her position would not be offered any kind of social housing as she is in employment. sad but unfortunately true. So many properties are under occupied, as a care worker I see lovely homes going to waste because people won't leave these properties to allow other families the chance of making happy memories with their children. I really feel for this lady, but is it really fair a single person should occupy a 3 bedroom council owned property when a married couple with 2 or 3 children have to share a 1 or 2 bedroom property?
I'm a sentimental person, so I also need familiar surroundings when I'm grieving - but as we're renting privately that's not an option. Having the same home for nearly 30 years is rare.
If we go through redundancy again and can't afford our rent any more we will have to find somewhere cheaper - with no help from the council (we don't 'qualify').
In the last year I've lost 3 family members (including our baby), but as a private tenant I have nothing more than photos and a few trinkets to remember them by.
Crease2000
says...
11:35am Fri 11 May 12
theavengers
says...
11:39am Fri 11 May 12
mandyc803
says...
11:41am Fri 11 May 12
Justsum1
says...
12:03pm Fri 11 May 12
Anything that the rest of the estate are receiving at present, she just wants her home, to be able to grieve surrounded by what she knows and loves. I am on the understanding that she nursed her sick mum, with no outside help and them She also did the same For her dad, whilst still holding down a job!! And for those who say its not her home then I totally disagree, it may not be her HOUSE but it is her HOME. Xx
itsonlyme2
says...
12:37pm Fri 11 May 12
Justsum1
says...
1:19pm Fri 11 May 12
stephie86
says...
1:36pm Fri 11 May 12
I understand that there are many people waiting to be housed....ive been on that list for years...but i would happily give up my space if it meant that Angela could have some peace (even if only a little) that she is surrounded by memories of the people she loved.
Angela is not asking for handouts, she is just asking for a little peace to help her grieve.......not a lot to ask really?!
Keep strong Ange, GREEN ARMY!! xxxxxx
emelem
says...
1:58pm Fri 11 May 12
i don't think i would want to be in the same space where i lost so many people in such a short space of time, but i speculate~
maybe she could start writing a journal (also therapeutic) of the memories the home holds for her (the dancing, the taking the mick, etc), that can't be captured in material possessions, as well as taking material possessions with her?
i don't know...
but good luck and be strong, angela
mumto3
says...
2:57pm Fri 11 May 12
GREEN ARMY ALL THE WAY XX
Crease2000
says...
3:18pm Fri 11 May 12
star_123
says...
3:20pm Fri 11 May 12
It seems so unfair that it couldn't be handed down once again, why is this rule in place that it can only be succeeded once? this needs to change for people in this situation in the future.
It is especially awful as they were planning on buying the property.
I have 3 children and we are all in a 2 bedroom property but reading this story I would 100% rather Angela stay in there then have her kicked out just so we have a bit more space. Having children was my choice and I knew it would be a squash but thats the decision we made. Losing her family AND home is not Angela's choice. Have a heart people can't you see what is right??
I AM 100% GOING TO SIGN THIS PETITION
Good luck Angela and well done to the 4000+ ppl who have already signed
Sutton53
says...
3:59pm Fri 11 May 12
shell74
says...
3:59pm Fri 11 May 12
living there, I know of cases like this & they get to stay so it should be no different the other way round, half the time the council make the rules up as they go along. Good luck Angela!
smallsteps
says...
4:58pm Fri 11 May 12
1978_ leigh
says...
6:23pm Fri 11 May 12
GREEN ARMY ALL THE WAY ..... And if nyone had a heart they would also go on line n sign this petition.....
21kmuffett
says...
10:01pm Fri 11 May 12
!!!.. GREEN ARMY ..!!!
Csmewing
says...
10:40pm Fri 11 May 12
AlphaBetty wrote:You say you think its heartbreaking what this lady has been through and yet you make this comment, its not the fact whether she needs a 3 bedroom home or not its the fact that this is her home and has been for nearly 30 years this home of hers has very precious memories why should she have to leave it?? is it not enough that she has lost everything else?? how much more do you want her to suffer?? You call yourself a care worker not much caring in your comment is there?? And as for the person who has also left a comment about them renting privately you have the same rights as everyone to bid on the choice based lettings scheme so obviously your doing something wrong to be in the situation that your in!!!! and if you were made redundant again as you say you would be entitled to benefits until you found employment again...I think you all sound selfish and heartless and if you all had a home that you loved you wouldn't even be making these comments because you would be happy with your lot, but instead you sound bitter because you want what she has....none of you obviously have a clue what its like to live her life with the pain and grief every single day and not being able to see the light at the end of the tunnel, grow a heart and stop thinking what is lawfully right and think what is morally right for a change...rant over...
suttonmum wrote:Totally agree with Suttonmum. I understand that she's been through a lot, but this is a family-sized home. Previously living there for many years doesn't give you an automatic right to stay there forever.
It really is hearbreaking what this poor lady has gone through over the last 2 years, but the fact is she really doesn't need a 3 bedroom house. There are so many families in homes too small for them, and I don't mean those on benefits who continue having children. I mean hard working families who work hard and still cannot afford a suitably sized home for their families. If the council are prepared to offer this lady a 1 bedroom property, it should be accepted as many young women in her position would not be offered any kind of social housing as she is in employment. sad but unfortunately true. So many properties are under occupied, as a care worker I see lovely homes going to waste because people won't leave these properties to allow other families the chance of making happy memories with their children. I really feel for this lady, but is it really fair a single person should occupy a 3 bedroom council owned property when a married couple with 2 or 3 children have to share a 1 or 2 bedroom property?
I'm a sentimental person, so I also need familiar surroundings when I'm grieving - but as we're renting privately that's not an option. Having the same home for nearly 30 years is rare.
If we go through redundancy again and can't afford our rent any more we will have to find somewhere cheaper - with no help from the council (we don't 'qualify').
In the last year I've lost 3 family members (including our baby), but as a private tenant I have nothing more than photos and a few trinkets to remember them by.
Csmewing
says...
10:43pm Fri 11 May 12
Csmewing
says...
10:57pm Fri 11 May 12
the_way_we_are
says...
12:51am Sat 12 May 12
mandyc803 wrote:i do see what you are saying, but those people who live in large houses alone, have a legally binding tenancy, Mrs Green doesnt, and i do not think in these current housing situation, the heart should rule the head, you cant change rules just because you feel sorry for a person, as every person in the world would have something that has happened to them that they feel special circumstances should be granted, if Mr Green was still alive, would everyone be doing this because Mrs Greens father had passed and shp were asking for their home back??? i do honestly hope that Mrs Greens suffering and pain eases in time
I also know Angela and Darren i also will support Angela 110% in this she does not deserve any of this, now i know of many a council house where a 1 person is living in a 3/4 bed house but just because they are the named tenant they get to stay how is this fair should the rules not still apply that there are people need housing, so why not let her stay its not like she just moved in she has lived there all her life and wanted to continue living there a married couple with her husband, yes there are people waiting, but i agree with glen no decent human being would want to take her home away from her,i just hope shp are very proud of themselves doing this to a young lady who hasn't had time to accept or grieve for these family members let alone have the energy to deal with this,all I can say is well done you, hope U sleep well at night. Darren was a extremely lovely man who we all loved dearly now i know he will be very proud of his wife and family and would want everyone supporting her so that's exactly what i intend to do. xx
BrokenInBritain
says...
8:26am Sat 12 May 12
myself, my wife and our son lived in a three bedroom flat with my wife's parents, brother, sister and her partner and his daughter for four years whilst waiting for a 2 bedroom council property. if this young girl had to be evicted so i could be housed quicker then i would have turned it down. the girl has suffered enough already.
And if Mr Green was still alive then im sure Angela would still fight tooth and nail for a house which SHP were more than happy to sell her just a few short months ago.
star_123
says...
8:39am Sat 12 May 12
suttonmum
says...
11:11am Sat 12 May 12
10:57pm Fri 11 May 12
You say you think its heartbreaking what this lady has been through and yet you make this comment, its not the fact whether she needs a 3 bedroom home or not its the fact that this is her home and has been for nearly 30 years this home of hers has very precious memories why should she have to leave it?? is it not enough that she has lost everything else?? how much more do you want her to suffer?? You call yourself a care worker not much caring in your comment is there?? And as for the person who has also left a comment about them renting privately you have the same rights as everyone to bid on the choice based lettings scheme so obviously your doing something wrong to be in the situation that your in!!!! and if you were made redundant again as you say you would be entitled to benefits until you found employment again...I think you all sound selfish and heartless and if you all had a home that you loved you wouldn't even be making these comments because you would be happy with your lot, but instead you sound bitter because you want what she has....none of you obviously have a clue what its like to live her life with the pain and grief every single day and not being able to see the light at the end of the tunnel, grow a heart and stop thinking what is lawfully right and think what is morally right for a change...rant over...
Trust me I am not bitter or unhappy with my lot, I am merely voicing an opinion, as is every one else on here. A lot of people who have posted comments appear to know this lady personally and so see it differently to how others might. At the end of the day I am not taking away what Angela has been through but she would not be the first person to have to leave a council property because the legal tennants have passed. It happens all the time regardless of the amount of time they have lived there or what memerories they may have. Yes SHP could have handled this situation better, but they are not making this lady homesless. Most other people in the same situation,who are in employment wouldn't even be offered a council property as they would not meet the criteria and would have to find themselves alternative privately rented accomadation. People suffer loss every day and unfortuanately for social housing to become available for new families people often have to pass away or move to smaller properties when they are no longer in need of the size property they have. I am not being heartless or uncaring and do think Mrs Green should have been left to grieve instead of being asked to leave the property so soon after her loss.
working mum121
says...
11:58am Sat 12 May 12
halhal
says...
1:07pm Sat 12 May 12
catuk123
says...
1:23pm Sat 12 May 12
The negative people who commented need to think with their heart on a situation like this,1 house out of all that sutton housing own is not going to make a huge impact on the housing list,but it will make a huge impact on a fragile Lady who is broken in 2!!.
x Green Army x
Justsum1
says...
2:26pm Sat 12 May 12
www.greenarmy.me.uk
thankyou xx
Eeyore79
says...
5:51pm Sat 12 May 12
Justsum1
says...
6:00pm Sat 12 May 12
. So instead of freein up her huge house with massive front and back gardens for a 2 bed, they have refused outright, very strange policies x
Justsum1
says...
6:01pm Sat 12 May 12
JPR
says...
11:20am Sun 13 May 12
Poor creatures they will be very soon replaced with a machine with more heart they never imagine they would have.
And a machine can not lie.
Crease2000
says...
12:37pm Sun 13 May 12
the_way_we_are
says...
12:49pm Sun 13 May 12
Crease2000 wrote:im guessing that she doesnt have a tenancy though, as this is the problem from what i understand, so i doubt she has any legal right as far as a tenant would have, i hope she has stopped paying them any rent whilst this has been going on!!!
If nothing else, those awful SHP can serve a section 21 and that would give Angela 2 months to move. Even then if she plays it right, she could refuse to move and then the SHP would have to take her to court which would give her more time. A tenancy agreement protects the landlord AND the tenant and I hope that she uses the contract to it's full effect. There's no mention that her rent isn't being paid, so s0d them.
Crease2000
says...
12:59pm Sun 13 May 12
Wait right there
says...
5:23pm Sun 13 May 12
the_way_we_are wrote:even an those without a tenancy cannot be removed without a court order. It is sad that she must leave her family home and I hope she does get priority and a new start.
Crease2000 wrote:im guessing that she doesnt have a tenancy though, as this is the problem from what i understand, so i doubt she has any legal right as far as a tenant would have, i hope she has stopped paying them any rent whilst this has been going on!!!
If nothing else, those awful SHP can serve a section 21 and that would give Angela 2 months to move. Even then if she plays it right, she could refuse to move and then the SHP would have to take her to court which would give her more time. A tenancy agreement protects the landlord AND the tenant and I hope that she uses the contract to it's full effect. There's no mention that her rent isn't being paid, so s0d them.
Justsum1 says...
8:08am Fri 11 May 12