Save St Helier Campaign has cross-party support in Merton and Sutton

Stephen Alambritis, leader of Merton Council, is fighting proposals to axe St Helier Hospital's A&E and maternity services Stephen Alambritis, leader of Merton Council, is fighting proposals to axe St Helier Hospital's A&E and maternity services

A campaign to stop the closure of accident and emergency and maternity departments has cross-party support.

In Merton and Sutton the Conservative, Lib Dem, and Labour groups have said they will oppose the loss of the frontline services at the hospital.

St Helier stands to lose both its A&E and maternity services as part of the NHS’s Better Service, Better Value healthcare review.

On Wednesday last week a panel of 60 representatives made up from south west London hospital trusts, local authority members and community representatives, recommended St Helier lose its frontline services over Croydon University and Kingston hospital.

A final decision on whether to shut the services is subject to more NHS scrutiny and a public consultation.

Labour councillor Stephen Alambritis, leader of Merton Council, said: "This Government is starving the NHS of funding. This has led to the shocking decision to close St. Helier's A&E and maternity services. I want to send a message to this Tory-led Government.

"The people of Merton will not take this decision lying down. We will fight any attempt to downgrade our local hospital and proposals to cut our A&E and maternity services."

Councillor Linda Kirby, Merton's cabinet member for adult social care and health, said: "I am hugely disappointed by this decision. I know local residents will be appalled. This will make life much more difficult for ill and disabled residents who will now need to travel much further for NHS care."

Conservative Health Spokesperson, councillor Suzanne Evans, spoke out at the South West London Joint Health Overview and Scrutiny Commission (JHOSC) on Thursday night, a meeting held specifically to question the process, and left unconvinced that the move will benefit patients in Merton.

She said: "St Helier’s A&E and Maternity departments are busier than ever and the numbers of people using them are only likely to increase," she says. "And why, when the NHS says it wants to diminish health inequalities, is it considering closing units in a deprived area, with high numbers of older people, and residents who’ll struggle to travel to other hospitals because they have to use public transport?"

"It’s hard not to be cynical about this; we’ve always feared it would be St Helier that loses A&E and Maternity services and that BSBV would champion the other SW London hospitals at the expense of St Helier. The BSBV team is saying this isn’t a ‘done deal’ but they’ll have to make an incredibly strong case for closure if they are to convince us on this. Meanwhile, we’ll be putting up a strong fight."

Comments(10)

Sutton53 says...
12:25pm Sun 13 May 12

If St Helier A & E is closed where are the 'overflow' from St. George's going to be sent?. At the moment they are re-directed to St. Helier. Also, how are the other hospitals going to cope with an increased number of women giving birth if St. Helier's Maternity Unit is closed? There is no way I would have got to St. George's let alone Croydon in time to give birth and I had complications with the birth.

Margaret_Hale says...
1:00pm Sun 13 May 12

It may be according to Labour councillor Stephen Alambritis, leader of Merton Councila "Tory-led coalition" but I seem to remember that our LibDem MP Paul Burstow is a government minister in the Dept of Health. Does he have anything to say about this?

Michael Pantlin says...
3:20pm Sun 13 May 12

Margaret_Hale wrote:
It may be according to Labour councillor Stephen Alambritis, leader of Merton Councila "Tory-led coalition" but I seem to remember that our LibDem MP Paul Burstow is a government minister in the Dept of Health. Does he have anything to say about this?
I think Mr. Photo Opportunity is part of the problem rather than the solution.

Michael Pantlin says...
4:01pm Sun 13 May 12

A few years back when it was decided that a new St. Helier Hospital was to be built adjacent to the Royal Marsden at Belmont, the then snooty Health Minister Patricia Hewitt stepped in and put the block on it. So it follows that now the politicians can if they have the will end this nonsensical policy that one hospital must be run down and degraded from its District General Hospital status. It's so obvious we need them all.

Michael Pantlin says...
4:01pm Sun 13 May 12

A few years back when it was decided that a new St. Helier Hospital was to be built adjacent to the Royal Marsden at Belmont, the then snooty Health Minister Patricia Hewitt stepped in and put the block on it. So it follows that now the politicians can if they have the will end this nonsensical policy that one hospital must be run down and degraded from its District General Hospital status. It's so obvious we need them all.

AlphaBetty says...
4:26pm Mon 14 May 12

I still don't fully understand what information they're basing this decision on. You could argue that in some parts of the country an accident and emergency department is more than 15 miles away - by comparison south London is practically swimming in hospitals. However, in London the roads are busier and the population density is higher.

Is it not financially viable? Well, find out why and address it sympathetically. Closing down major departments (or the whole thing) is a last resort.

Clearly we need all the hospitals we have, because they never seem empty. So what are they not telling us?

kazza76 says...
10:11pm Mon 14 May 12

myself and some friends have set up a group to campaign against the closures at st helier hospital it is appalling what is happening and management should not be allowing this we have been out over the weekend with petitions and posters to try and make locals aware of the proposals please sign our petitions in the local shops around morden, cheam and rose hill also please feel free to join our facebook page on the following link
https://www.facebook
.com/groups/21562552
8555482/218017668316
268/?comment_id=2188
69378231097&notif_t=
group_comment_reply
or by typing in on facebook save st helier maternity and a&e
many thanks in advance for the support we are also hoping to arrange a public meeting and a rally we also have an online petition on the site too.

Michael Pantlin says...
9:40pm Tue 15 May 12

kazza76 wrote:
myself and some friends have set up a group to campaign against the closures at st helier hospital it is appalling what is happening and management should not be allowing this we have been out over the weekend with petitions and posters to try and make locals aware of the proposals please sign our petitions in the local shops around morden, cheam and rose hill also please feel free to join our facebook page on the following link
https://www.facebook

.com/groups/21562552

8555482/218017668316

268/?comment_id=2188

69378231097¬if_t=
group_comment_reply
or by typing in on facebook save st helier maternity and a&e
many thanks in advance for the support we are also hoping to arrange a public meeting and a rally we also have an online petition on the site too.
Sadly my pc wouldn't come up with your site when I repeatedly tried but found a nice comprehsive article on the St. Helier tangle on
http://insidecroydon
.com/2012/05/10/st-h
elier-decision-puts-
sutton-mp-burstow-on
-the-spot/

Daniel Dunican says...
11:59am Sat 19 May 12

I really hope who ever decided the idea to close the A and E gets injured badly in a accident around Sutton then has to go all the way to St Georges to suffer the pain it will cause.

kazza76 says...
6:41pm Tue 22 May 12

@ daniel dunican i totally agree.
@micheal pantin type in on facebook save st helier maternity and a&e in the search bar it will come up with our group.
we have done n interview with radio jackie today and it should be aired either tommorrow or thursday morning.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree